Our Thinking

How adults grow

As adults develop, the way they make sense of the world changes shape. So does what they can see, and what they can handle.

Where it comes from

Adults keep developing long after school ends

For much of the last century, psychologists assumed adult thinking was mostly set by early adulthood. Constructive-developmental theory showed otherwise. Building on Jean Piaget's work with children, Robert Kegan and others found that adults move through a predictable series of levels. Each level reorganizes how a person understands themselves, other people, and their circumstances. Each one makes new things possible, and each one lets a person see the limits of the previous level for the first time.

Vertical Growth is the most powerful applied process to come out of that tradition. Keith Eigel and Karl Kuhnert set it out in their book The Map, drawing on level assessments of more than a thousand highly educated professionals. Their central finding is that a leader's current level of development is the best single measure of how effective that leader is, across industry, education, position, skill set, and personality.

This gives leaders a way to understand resistance to change that goes deeper than motivation, strategy, or skill. A manager who freezes when two senior people disagree, or who reads every bit of critical feedback as a reason to quit, may not need another course. That manager may be working at the edge of the lens they currently see through.

Lateral and Vertical

Two kinds of growth

Lateral growth is what we know. Vertical growth is how we know what we know. The everyday word for Vertical development is maturity: understanding ourselves, others, and our circumstances in more complete ways over time.

ACQUIRED KNOWLEDGE

Lateral development

  • What it does: Adds to what you know and do.
  • How long: Can happen in an afternoon.
  • Where: Schools, training sessions, seminars, books.
  • Example: Learning five steps for conflict resolution.

INSIGHT THAT CHANGED YOU

Vertical development

  • What it does: Changes how you understand what you know, what you do, and who you are.
  • How long: Months, sometimes years.
  • Where: Challenge that changes who you are in relation to it.
  • Example: Seeing the purpose and value of conflict in a new, more complete way.

The research

Four facts about Vertical growth

Lateral learning still matters. It opens doors, and it is how most people get promoted early in their careers. The Map names four facts about the other kind of growth.

1

It can be measured.

2

It follows a predictable order.

No one skips a level, and no one goes backward.

3

It is related to age without being determined by it.

The older we get, the more likely we are to stop growing.

4

The higher the level, the more effective the person.

That holds in leadership and in the rest of life.

85%

of adults stop growing at Level 4 or below.

35% stop at Level 3 or below, and 10% stop at Level 2. Vertical growth occurs naturally over time. It's measurable and can be accelerated.

The Map

The levels of adult development

The Map describes five levels. Level 1 belongs to early childhood, so the adult road runs from Level 2 to Level 5. Each level works like a lens. You can't see your current lens while you are looking through it, but you keep access to the ones you have outgrown. That is why understanding becomes more complete at each step.

Nobody jumps from one level to the next. The book splits each level into fifths (3.0, 3.2, 3.4 and so on), because the influence of the level you are leaving fades slowly as the next one takes hold.

2.0.2.4.6.83.0.2.4.6.84.0.2.4.6.85.0

2

It's all about me

Outside-In · concrete · win or lose. The world sorts into simple categories: right or wrong, good or bad, winner or loser. Rules are followed when the reward or the consequence is big enough. People at this level assume everyone else acts from self-interest too, so there is steady suspicion.

What it makes possible: a clear sense that reality exists apart from my own perceptions, and the drive to win within it. Where it runs out: empathy. A Level 2 person can see that your position differs from theirs without being able to understand it.

Normal around age twelve. In an adult it means development has stalled. Level 2 leaders often rise on intelligence and expertise, and stall once leading requires coordinating with others.

2 → 3: a “win” in not winning

3

Overwhelmed by outside influences

Outside-In · shaped by valued others. Understanding is adopted from the people and groups we value most: first peers, then organizations, culture, and political or religious ideologies. We see ourselves the way others see us, and we spend a great deal of energy working out how we are perceived. Identity merges with role. "I am an accountant" in place of "I practice accounting."

What it makes possible: empathy, loyalty, and the ability to coordinate my agenda with other people's. Care for team morale. Where it runs out: when learned responses don't fit the situation, there is no self to turn to. In the book's words, "our circumstances handle us." Conflict gets smoothed over fast.

Healthy and normal in your twenties. Karl Kuhnert writes that most of the highly educated leaders the authors work with are somewhere in the move from Level 3 to Level 4.

3 → 4: the effectiveness transition, from Outside-In to Inside-Out

4

Taking ownership of your life

Inside-Out · self-authored. The leader builds a self-authored paradigm and asks, "What do I really hold to be true?" Emotions, relationships, and mistakes become mine to own. "He made me angry" becomes "I got angry when he did that." Feedback still matters, but it no longer defines the person. It refines them.

What it makes possible: the grounded confidence executives call gravitas. The ability to choose between competing loyalties, such as performance and relationship, and stand behind the choice. Where it runs out: assuming others see the world the same way. Success makes the paradigm feel like the only way, and it can harden into rigidity.

The book says it is not until we are more Level 4 than Level 3 that others see us as effective leaders. The shift often begins in the early to mid-thirties. Most people stop growing at Level 4 or before.

4 → 5: holding your own way with an open hand

5

Letting go and rising above

Inside-Out · grounded in higher-order values. The self-authored paradigm becomes something the leader can step back from and examine. It no longer defines them. Values such as honesty, integrity, courage, and openness to others hold the different perspectives together, so the leader can integrate views that look opposed. Conflict becomes useful instead of something to manage.

What it makes possible: humility, a focus on the growth of others, and decisions where everyone is heard and leaves committed even without full agreement. How it can look to others: too deliberate, or not decisive enough, because of the care taken to make sure people feel understood.

Rare, and most who reach it are in their sixties or older. It does not depend on education or intelligence. One of Keith's favorite Level 5 people was a 75-year-old brick mason with a sixth-grade education.

“

Challenges don't really get solved; rather, they wind up solving us.

Keith M. Eigel, The Map

How growth happens

The formula for Vertical Growth

(C + C) / T × P = VG

Challenge and Contradiction, divided by Time, multiplied by Perseverance, equals Vertical Growth: a new, more complete understanding that reconciles the contradiction.

C + C

Challenge and Contradiction

Something that bumps against the limits of how you currently understand things.

T

Time

The longer you take to work through the tension, the slower the growth.

P

Perseverance

Staying with the tension instead of masking or avoiding it. At zero, nothing grows.

VG

Vertical Growth

A new, more complete understanding that reconciles the contradiction.

Vertical development rarely happens when things are going your way. It comes after a challenge. A problem can be solved with a Lateral fix. A challenge asks more of you. In a conflict with a colleague, the problem is the conflict. The challenge is that it keeps you up at night.

The book compares a stuck level to wet concrete. You can walk through fresh concrete if you keep moving. The longer you stand in one place, the harder it sets, and the bigger the challenge it takes to break free. Growth also goes faster with other people involved. The Map calls these developmental relationships: people who share growth objectives, ask each other for ideas, and hold each other accountable.

In practice

What this means for leaders and organizations

Behavior alone does not show a person's level. Teach the same conflict skill to four leaders and each will use it through their own lens.

A new skill changes a leader's level only when it contradicts something they hold to be true and they work through that contradiction. Training that adds skills without that kind of challenge builds Lateral capability and leaves the lens where it was. Promoting the best salesperson or technician promotes Lateral skill, which is why organizations are often surprised when that person struggles to lead a team. As Karl Kuhnert puts it, "It's not what people say that is most important, but rather the level from which they are speaking."

The framework also puts responsibility on the person further along. A Level 4 leader can meet a Level 3 colleague where they are, because the Level 4 leader has been there. The reverse is not yet possible. Leaders who understand this stop reading every struggle on their team as a motivation or skill problem, and start asking what kind of challenge and support would help each person grow.

Level 2

Uses the conflict skill to push their own agenda.

Level 3

Uses it to avoid conflict and get along better.

Level 4

Uses it to reach the best solution.

Level 5

Uses the conflict to help others grow.

The book

The Map

By Keith M. Eigel, Ph.D. and Karl W. Kuhnert, Ph.D. The Map lays out the five levels of Vertical development, describes each one from the inside, and gives practical steps for growing from one level to the next. It includes the Growth Gap Tool, a five-step process for finding where you are stuck, based on a model by Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey.

Buy on Amazon

Go deeper

Vertical Leadership Groups

Small peer cohorts meet every other week for ten structured sessions. Each leader names a growth objective, takes small steps toward it between sessions, and works through what they learn with the group.

4–6 leaders per groupEvery other week10 sessions
Book a call